From the beginning, Dr. Mayakovsky sought the Royal Jelly
escape the world into a moment of bliss. But in the end, what he really wanted
was to be in the embrace of the woman he loved and to be with her. He was no
longer afraid of death. In addition, in his reprogramming of Gill, Gill awakes
to some minor human emotions as well, such as love. Gill’s sacrifice was his
own decision, not a forced command, in order to protect Julian. The tricked work so well because Captain
Potter believed that human emotions could only be found in humans, not
machines, nor that they could have free will. Technology and science claim to
understand the world, but consistently new things are being discovered. First, the alien robot could not match the scent of the alien hive,
even though all science said it would. Second, Gill “awoke” to emotions and
free will (syth are not permitted to let a human come to harm). While these are
sci-fi, they reflect the reality of the world. Science is always changing and
trying to prove or disprove things. What do you believe in when everything you
thought you knew is now a lie?
Another point you can see from this story is the
personification of Consequentialist, Perfectionist, and Deontological
viewpoints of ethics. Gill can be seen
as the Consequentialist, at least in the beginning. For a syth, he is governed
by the three rules of robotics: do not harm a human or allow a human to become
harmed, it must obey all commands unless in conflict with first, it must
protect its existence unless conflict with previous laws. Because of this, a syth
looks for the best for the most good. If anyone has to die, Gill wants to least
death. When Dr. Mayakovsky plans to go into the hive, Gill follows only because
the storm and potential of waiting in the open is slimmer than going through
the hive. His plans are rational and goal-oriented: save and protect his human
master. Dr. Mayakovsky plays the role of the Deontological view. His focus is
inter-personal relationships. He reprograms Gil to be free from the laws and
have free will because everyone should be free to choice. His goals were
universal; he wanted to live and be happy (which he did thanks to the Royal
Jelly) and wished this upon his robotic creations which he considered his own
family. Julian can be seen as the Perfectionist. Her original mission in coming
to Dr. Mayakovsky was to find a reliable source of obtaining Royal Jelly. She
trained herself daily in avoiding and escaping from Norbert, which also dueled
as allowing him to learn the nature of the aliens. This can be evidence of her strife to perfect
herself to the best that she could be, and to be a hero in the world by
returning with Royal Jelly. Her goal in this world is a worthy cause, the
plagues of mankind have grown stronger and the Royal Jelly can help people be
happy, or save lives, or other various uses when applied to science. In the
end, no theory is better than the other, as seen that each person dies in his
or her own noble way. Gill dies saving the most important people to him, and
Dr. Mayakovsky and Julian die in a loving embrace in bliss.
No comments:
Post a Comment